Hardball History
“Hardball History: Public Historians on the Edge of Politics, Advocacy, and Activism” was a session at the 2015 National Council on Public History conference in Nashville, Tennessee.
.@jhowardhistory @DrDanKerr @her_version Fear of losing authority, legitimacy; unexamined white privilege, class privilege #s27 #ncph2015
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 19, 2015
Believe fears of academics are grounded in unexamined privilege. Important to acknowledge that. #s27 #ncph2015 https://t.co/zu351LzQ6D
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 19, 2015
Thank you SO MUCH to all the #twitterstorians who recorded and reflected on #S27 #ncph2015 Let's keep this conversation going!
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 19, 2015
https://twitter.com/KryderReid/status/589176818005073921
https://twitter.com/KryderReid/status/589174249883054081
https://twitter.com/KryderReid/status/589173560956100610
Could not have run #S27 without @Philpo1Susan @CuppaCourtney @Stone92Stone, awesome note takers #ncph2015
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 17, 2015
.@HistorianOnFire raises important issue of how we talk about theory vs how it is used in words in exhibits #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Plan to tweet this one a bit less. Tired fingers from #s27 still. 😉 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
"@museumnotations: @DrDanKerr sees his role as a CrockPot. #ncph2015 #s27" that's the best ID ever.
— Barbara Little (@barbarajlittle) April 17, 2015
Very relevant to #s27 #ncph2015 also @anne_e_parsons (via @JoVanEvery) https://t.co/ovAyvLi71K
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/Stone92Stone/status/589082585730588672
Thanks to everyone on the #s27 panel: It's a hard nuanced conversation about hard nuanced work. #ncph2015
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
Hardball History panelists will develop some sort of public document with notes from #s27 #ncph2015 #publichistory
— Hope J. Shannon (@HistorianHope) April 17, 2015
If you liked this session, @DDMeringolo says let's keep it going in Baltimore! #s27 #ncph2015 #ncph2016
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr I appreciate how you frame the way public historians should ask different questions than social services folks. #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr on cutting through preformed narratives asks: "Tell me how the city has changed?" #oralhistory #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr asking community residents about how the city has changed encouraged their personal voices to come through #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: Describing how homeless are often req'd to show that they are the "deserving" poor #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr shares crockpot activism metaphor: slow cooking different flavors of ideas & politics w/community through dialogue #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
.@jhowardhistory @DrDanKerr @her_version Fear of losing authority, legitimacy; unexamined white privilege, class privilege #s27 #ncph2015
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 19, 2015
Believe fears of academics are grounded in unexamined privilege. Important to acknowledge that. #s27 #ncph2015 https://t.co/zu351LzQ6D
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 19, 2015
Thank you SO MUCH to all the #twitterstorians who recorded and reflected on #S27 #ncph2015 Let's keep this conversation going!
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 19, 2015
https://twitter.com/KryderReid/status/589176818005073921
https://twitter.com/KryderReid/status/589174249883054081
https://twitter.com/KryderReid/status/589173560956100610
Could not have run #S27 without @Philpo1Susan @CuppaCourtney @Stone92Stone, awesome note takers #ncph2015
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 17, 2015
.@HistorianOnFire raises important issue of how we talk about theory vs how it is used in words in exhibits #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Plan to tweet this one a bit less. Tired fingers from #s27 still. 😉 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
"@museumnotations: @DrDanKerr sees his role as a CrockPot. #ncph2015 #s27" that's the best ID ever.
— Barbara Little (@barbarajlittle) April 17, 2015
Very relevant to #s27 #ncph2015 also @anne_e_parsons (via @JoVanEvery) https://t.co/ovAyvLi71K
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/Stone92Stone/status/589082585730588672
Thanks to everyone on the #s27 panel: It's a hard nuanced conversation about hard nuanced work. #ncph2015
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
Hardball History panelists will develop some sort of public document with notes from #s27 #ncph2015 #publichistory
— Hope J. Shannon (@HistorianHope) April 17, 2015
If you liked this session, @DDMeringolo says let's keep it going in Baltimore! #s27 #ncph2015 #ncph2016
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr I appreciate how you frame the way public historians should ask different questions than social services folks. #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr on cutting through preformed narratives asks: "Tell me how the city has changed?" #oralhistory #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr asking community residents about how the city has changed encouraged their personal voices to come through #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: Describing how homeless are often req'd to show that they are the "deserving" poor #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr shares crockpot activism metaphor: slow cooking different flavors of ideas & politics w/community through dialogue #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr you don't know what will mobilize folks until you really get to know them. Be with them. Visitors first. #ncph2015 #S27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr sees his role as a CrockPot. Slow cook, bubble those long term relationships. Personal experiences. #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
SharED authority v. sharING authority – @DrDanKerr calling on Michael Frisch #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: argues for a slow cooker approach to activism; need to have room to respond to dialogue & change #ncph2015 #s27 #metaphorstho
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DDMeringolo powerful: more institutionalized an org became, the less they related and served the communities #ncph2015 #S27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
"What you choose to teach can be an active political gesture." – Nancy Berlage#ncph2015 #s27
— Sarah Atwood (@_sarahatwood) April 17, 2015
.@DDMeringolo asks how do we respond when asked about bias #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
@DDMeringolo: the more institutionalized an org becomes, the more rigid it becomes (re: @HistoryAndrea's book) #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
#ncph2015 #s27 It's hard to make people understand that it can be empowering not to have space… People want "a room of their own."
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
Calling all millionaires: donate to Yolanda Chavez Leyva & Museum Without Walls. Please. #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
A museum w/out physical walls can provide you w opportunities to work with new communities, organizations, exhibition topics #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
Leyva notes millionaires were brought to museum by a donor. They have nothing. Poor families from n'hood often gave $5 #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
#S27 has me recalling Howard Zinn's infamous quip about historians not being exempt if the world blows up. #NCPH2015
— Nick Sacco (@NickSacco55) April 17, 2015
Leyva: Millionaires visited at-risk site, gave nothing. Incredibly poor community members gave what they could (& couldn't) #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Yolanda Chavez Leyva: our public values space, safety, community, empathy, humanity. #S27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/elizabethcatte/status/589077972277194753
Having a physical space to learn about the past is a powerful, validating experience #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/K_Gannon/status/589077269529886721
https://twitter.com/OliviaLane87/status/589077173304164353
https://twitter.com/lwalterscooper/status/589077122020466688
.@jhowardhistory @DrDanKerr @her_version Fear of losing authority, legitimacy; unexamined white privilege, class privilege #s27 #ncph2015
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 19, 2015
Believe fears of academics are grounded in unexamined privilege. Important to acknowledge that. #s27 #ncph2015 https://t.co/zu351LzQ6D
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 19, 2015
Thank you SO MUCH to all the #twitterstorians who recorded and reflected on #S27 #ncph2015 Let's keep this conversation going!
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 19, 2015
https://twitter.com/KryderReid/status/589176818005073921
https://twitter.com/KryderReid/status/589174249883054081
https://twitter.com/KryderReid/status/589173560956100610
Could not have run #S27 without @Philpo1Susan @CuppaCourtney @Stone92Stone, awesome note takers #ncph2015
— Denise D. Meringolo (@DDMeringolo) April 17, 2015
.@HistorianOnFire raises important issue of how we talk about theory vs how it is used in words in exhibits #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Plan to tweet this one a bit less. Tired fingers from #s27 still. 😉 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
"@museumnotations: @DrDanKerr sees his role as a CrockPot. #ncph2015 #s27" that's the best ID ever.
— Barbara Little (@barbarajlittle) April 17, 2015
Very relevant to #s27 #ncph2015 also @anne_e_parsons (via @JoVanEvery) https://t.co/ovAyvLi71K
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/Stone92Stone/status/589082585730588672
Thanks to everyone on the #s27 panel: It's a hard nuanced conversation about hard nuanced work. #ncph2015
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
Hardball History panelists will develop some sort of public document with notes from #s27 #ncph2015 #publichistory
— Hope J. Shannon (@HistorianHope) April 17, 2015
If you liked this session, @DDMeringolo says let's keep it going in Baltimore! #s27 #ncph2015 #ncph2016
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr I appreciate how you frame the way public historians should ask different questions than social services folks. #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr on cutting through preformed narratives asks: "Tell me how the city has changed?" #oralhistory #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr asking community residents about how the city has changed encouraged their personal voices to come through #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: Describing how homeless are often req'd to show that they are the "deserving" poor #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr shares crockpot activism metaphor: slow cooking different flavors of ideas & politics w/community through dialogue #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr you don't know what will mobilize folks until you really get to know them. Be with them. Visitors first. #ncph2015 #S27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr sees his role as a CrockPot. Slow cook, bubble those long term relationships. Personal experiences. #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
SharED authority v. sharING authority – @DrDanKerr calling on Michael Frisch #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: argues for a slow cooker approach to activism; need to have room to respond to dialogue & change #ncph2015 #s27 #metaphorstho
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DDMeringolo powerful: more institutionalized an org became, the less they related and served the communities #ncph2015 #S27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
"What you choose to teach can be an active political gesture." – Nancy Berlage#ncph2015 #s27
— Sarah Atwood (@_sarahatwood) April 17, 2015
.@DDMeringolo asks how do we respond when asked about bias #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
@DDMeringolo: the more institutionalized an org becomes, the more rigid it becomes (re: @HistoryAndrea's book) #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
#ncph2015 #s27 It's hard to make people understand that it can be empowering not to have space… People want "a room of their own."
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
Calling all millionaires: donate to Yolanda Chavez Leyva & Museum Without Walls. Please. #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
A museum w/out physical walls can provide you w opportunities to work with new communities, organizations, exhibition topics #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
Leyva notes millionaires were brought to museum by a donor. They have nothing. Poor families from n'hood often gave $5 #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
#S27 has me recalling Howard Zinn's infamous quip about historians not being exempt if the world blows up. #NCPH2015
— Nick Sacco (@NickSacco55) April 17, 2015
Leyva: Millionaires visited at-risk site, gave nothing. Incredibly poor community members gave what they could (& couldn't) #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Yolanda Chavez Leyva: our public values space, safety, community, empathy, humanity. #S27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/elizabethcatte/status/589077972277194753
Having a physical space to learn about the past is a powerful, validating experience #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/K_Gannon/status/589077269529886721
https://twitter.com/OliviaLane87/status/589077173304164353
https://twitter.com/lwalterscooper/status/589077122020466688
History is a site where power structures are reproduced. #ncph2015 #s27
— AnneBradenInstitute (@ABIatUofL) April 17, 2015
History is a site of power #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Any other small museum profs in #ncph2015 #s27? Thoughts on scope of discussion? trying to place myself within the academia/large org focus
— Theresa Koenigsknecht (@TKhistarch7) April 17, 2015
Historian shares how when she worked for the federal govt compromised her personal integrity & affected her emotionally. #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
@DDMeringolo's "activish" term getting a lot of love. #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Q3 #s27 : How do you make this work stable for you emotionally and financially? #ncph2015
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
Great insight from woman working at civil war battlefield: being a different face in an unexpected place is form of activism. #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
So many good thoughts, questions, challenges in #s27 Glad I got out of bed for this one #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Great audience comment on #s27 Language itself as powerful form of activism on front lines & in classroom #ncph2015
— Theresa Koenigsknecht (@TKhistarch7) April 17, 2015
Aud: NPS rangers told not to take a side, but it IS taking a side–the side of the dominant narrative. #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Aud comment: Calling slavery a crime against humanity changes the conversation #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589074801756614656
@DrDanKerr says public historian-activists have to take personal risks in opposing power that maintains systemic inequality. #S27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: Our social/cultural moment is brutally violent & deeply unequal #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
#s27 Everyone is talking about "risks" in activism & publichistory – can we define these risks please! @DrDanKerr @DDMeringolo #ncph2015
— Courtney Neaveill (@her_version) April 17, 2015
Aud comment: as a white woman in classroom, more room to get mad about racist comments in class, are judged differently #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Safety as a form of #privilege (Summarizing @DDMeringolo 's brilliance) #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@DDMeringolo the idea of being safe and unsafe in your profession goes back to choice. Subjectivities, privileges, #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/K_Gannon/status/589074114171678720
Challenging structural oppression involves risk and we need to be willing to take these risks, @drdankerr #ncph2015 #s27 #publichistory
— Hope J. Shannon (@HistorianHope) April 17, 2015
.@DDMeringolo choice to take risk or not IS a privilege #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/elizabethcatte/status/589073931132350464
Now we're cooking with gas: Public historians discussing their white privilege #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
.@DrDanKerr talking abt fear, risks, noting this moment. When can take risks? I add it reminds me of risks others fave daily #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589073747098865664
@DrDanKerr: Activism is inherently risky. How & when are we willing to take those risks #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DDMeringolo responds: It's difficult, historically #publichistory has been conservative. #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
Language and rhetoric is important when doing advocacy work. #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589073436019970048
@DDMeringolo: It's actually hard to find examples of progressive activism in the history of PH #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Q #s27 : We've been talking about progressive activism, how do you deal with conservative activism? #ncph2015
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/PubHistPhD/status/589073276019826689
Audience comment: There is also conservative activism at work in the culture #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/npdecicco/status/589073208973914112
"We're not just talking to the choir." – Nancy Berlage on activism in #publichistory #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/PubHistPhD/status/589073031047356416
https://twitter.com/elizabethcatte/status/589072969399463937
@abbygateau Time, energy, empathy is needed to break down misconceptions & barriers. Community relations is so important. #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/K_Gannon/status/589072945781309440
@NickSacco55 : We need patience and time in activist-y-engaged public history #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@K_Gannon yes! http://t.co/YzpgFJO8TO #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Audiences grappling with how these strategies/goals can bridge academy/nonacademy divide and regional differences. Thoughts? #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589072661621383168
https://twitter.com/npdecicco/status/589072613630210049
Academia can often seem safer but for adjuncts there are different risks. #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
@DDMeringolo : Sometimes it's important to reach out to community partners if you can't act in your own official role. #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
@k10death: Being an activist in a classroom is not safe w/in academia bc academy is under more pol scrutiny #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Black museum movement: on the front lines of activism for a century now! #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Andrea Burns (@HistoryAndrea) April 17, 2015
So then maybe consider working to be a better, more considerate partner as a way of being activist #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
"We put the panel and realized we're all in the academy and said oh crap." –@cathystanton #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@SusanChumley Adds a good component to our convo – our work as activists is conditioned by our subjectivity as laborers. #s27 #ncph2015
— Sarah Atwood (@_sarahatwood) April 17, 2015
My Q: but if you're part of the Fed govt, doesn't that make it hard for communities who were hurt by fed govt to trust you? #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
#ncph2015 #s27 @cathystanton : We need compassion for people in the field. Sometimes you can't work in official capacity.
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/elizabethcatte/status/589071948489031680
https://twitter.com/K_Gannon/status/589071885037662209
https://twitter.com/PubHistPhD/status/589071812350386177
NPS Rangers outing themselves all over #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@her_version a picture to go with the tweets! #ncph2015 #s27 pic.twitter.com/LzxTHRUku4
— IFPH Stu & New Prof (@IFPHStuPro) April 17, 2015
One attendee advised: "You should just do the #socialjustice work without calling it that … people support the ideas." #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
Panelist A to that? You have to take sides. Ppl need to see you are with them. #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Confession: When I was a park ranger, ppl called me officer. I did not correct them. #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Great aud Q: what about NPS? How do we be activists? In my area ppl think we are basically cops? #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Note from audience: if you do social justice work but don't call it that, can get a lot more support in conservative areas. #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/ModupeLabode/status/589071151160242176
https://twitter.com/npdecicco/status/589071139844030465
Audience member: Park Rangers wear badges & WWI uniforms #realtalk #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Comment from @abbygateau: sometimes we should just do the social justice work and not call it that. Ppl will get on board #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589071014962851840
https://twitter.com/elizabethcatte/status/589070895379021827
https://twitter.com/PubHistPhD/status/589070380133982209
.@DDMeringolo notes students in a class understand power dynamic in particular way, different from community work. That's it! #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Aaron Cowen from Slippery Rock- your students are your community too. #NCPH2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/npdecicco/status/589070062646120448
Work in the classroom is so important, but I'm not comfortable when folks bring it up as public history. Not sure why. #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
@cathystanton notes difference between serving communities & charging them with tasks, & to be mindful between the division. #ncph2015 #s27
— Sarah Atwood (@_sarahatwood) April 17, 2015
Yolanda Chavez Leyva: My vision for public history is to create a space for human beings. #icouldcryrightnow #feelings #S27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/OliviaLane87/status/589069596491132928
@DrDanKerr offered a critical point- listen. Establish affectionate relationships with your community. #NCPH2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
Q: How do you reach people who don't share your values? #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
Obsessed w/ #s27 at #NCPH2015. Thanks to all of the #twitterstorians for making it possible to follow along! @DrDanKerr @DDMeringolo @ncph
— Courtney Neaveill (@her_version) April 17, 2015
Great Q from @artiflection: does activist history risk only talking to those who agree? Having no audience at all? #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
"That is part of my vision to #publichistory , is to create a space that we're acknowledged as human beings." – Yolanda Leyva #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
On vision as a public historian- "to create a space where everyone is acknowledged as human beings" #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/npdecicco/status/589068911854936064
https://twitter.com/OliviaLane87/status/589068885057474560
Public history created, acknowledged an elder woman's experiences with the farm workers movement of the 50s. Humanity win #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Dr. Yolanda Chavez Leyva works to "create a space where we are acknowledged as human beings." #ncph2015 #s27
— Sarah Atwood (@_sarahatwood) April 17, 2015
Public history can create space that acknowledges & validates the experiences of community members #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
"Vision can be personal. Before their museum had walls, we had them". #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
In order to create change, there has to be spaces for critical reflection. – @DrDanKerr #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: Part of change is finding space for critical reflection #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr if you want to create movement, you need spaces for critical reflection. #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
.@DrDanKerr: what are ppl living in encampments' ideas for improvement? #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr describing his own history of activism & manning the barricades #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: public historians MUST actively listen to and collaborate with communities if our work is to be transformative #s27 #ncph2015
— Sarah Atwood (@_sarahatwood) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: Inclusive community mobilization/dialogue creates social change, not influencing top-down policy. #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/npdecicco/status/589067837844680704
https://twitter.com/OliviaLane87/status/589067776024776707
@DrDanKerr asks what are the things people in your community are willing to mobilize around? Start with a community dialogue. #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
.@DrDanKerr notes the vested interests in sustaining various inequalities, etc. writing a great book isn't transformative #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/K_Gannon/status/589067508591788032
@DrDanKerr : There are systemic interests in sustaining inequality. You cannot convince those interests by writing a book. #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: There are vested interests who want to perpetuate structural inequalities. Writing books is not enough. #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@cathystanton says public historians should push edge of our field and pull back on the passion of worlds of activism. #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
@cathystanton notes that in times of urgency, you still need space for reflection #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
@cathystanton: It's possible to be a conservative to some and a radical to another #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/OliviaLane87/status/589066882633830400
https://twitter.com/npdecicco/status/589066665503170560
.@cathystanton argues not to get caught up in a short view, feeling like historians haven't been here before #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
@cathystanton living in a moment of urgent choices, you can't get too caught up in short sided passion. #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/K_Gannon/status/589066479066308609
RT @abbygateau: @cathystanton gives @aleiabrown a shoutout for her History@Work post #ncph2015 #s27 http://t.co/ZawKuXB9GR
— Priya Chhaya (@priyastoric) April 17, 2015
The participants within #s27 are talking around not only professional values, but are also illuminating the role of vocation. #ncph2015
— Sarah Atwood (@_sarahatwood) April 17, 2015
@cathystanton knows that sometimes things we work on are antithetical to our values #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
@cathystanton : Sometimes as historians our work is used for ends antithetical to our goals. #gentrification #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@cathystanton: Our #publichistory work can contribute to projects antithetical to our ethics & we need to be mindful of that. #S27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
@cathystanton : "Rigor is a balance to passion." #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589066067361845248
@cathystanton gives @aleiabrown a shoutout for her History@Work post #ncph2015 #s27 http://t.co/jORVaECEmJ
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Q2: Are you working towards a specific goal or outcome? #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@cathystanton "The big question– what do you want your work to contribute to?" #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
Super glad to see grad students making notes about #s27 to share as a document later! #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Attendee suggests we can collect politically with more recent history, but not ancient history. Thoughts? #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589065236398927872
Aud comment: a coin does have three sides; it's just that few people recognize that third one #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Audience comment– even coins have 3 sides. The 3rd side just doesn't get much support! #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
A coin does have 3 sides, but third side needs a lot of support–audience member #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/K_Gannon/status/589065113367351296
.@DDMeringolo notes students finally recognize all history is political, but public history is political in a different way #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/OliviaLane87/status/589064840016199681
"Not choosing a side is choosing a side" – @DrDanKerr #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
#ncph2015 #s27 Great comment from the audience on the importance of breaking down binary language that is so divisive. Finding common groun
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
Yolanda Chavez Leyva: I wanted to bring my ethics into my professional life, my social justice commitment. #S27 #NCPH2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
In my own work, being "apolitical" usually means supporting status quo values like white supremacy, patriarchy #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Panelists point out how important it is to have mentors / to mentor in order to nurture turning justice thinking into action #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
Finally someone said it: "not choosing a side IS choosing a side" #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: "Not choosing sides is choosing a side" YES. #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
"what can I do that my teachers did for me? You don't need to accept things are the way they are." #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
Cynthia Renteria: city revitalization characterizes people as against or for "progress." More complicated than that. #S27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
Often being involved means getting outside of your comfort zone & pushing past your fear #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr : Choosing sides may be more committing to people to stand behind and stand up for #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/OliviaLane87/status/589063404465324033
@DrDanKerr " have committment to people not necessarily their ethics, we each have our own ethics" #s27 #ncph2015
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
@DrDanKerr: "revitalizing" neighborhoods often dispossesses the poor/working class. It's about power. #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
More for #publichumanitiesbingo : Rhetoric of progress, revitalization, & renaissance being used by powersthatbe to strongarm #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
Progress vs preservation is a false dichotomy #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
Panelists discuss choosing sides, @cathystanton reminds us that it's not just group v. group, but transparency v. otherwise #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@cathystanton — notes that you can choose transparency over opaque process #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/K_Gannon/status/589062661154934784
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589062610978480130
Sometimes divisiveness occurs. Either you are for or against x. But her philosophy is to bring 2gther history & community. #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
Renteria wanted her work to value community, people, history, & culture; how she got involved in activism #ncph2015 #s27
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
Hearing about putting progress in opposition to scholarship, history #s27 #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
#ncph2015 #s27 Renteria– inspired by the diversity of people coming together to address controversial development in El Paso.
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
"revitalization" & "progress" can be coded language for redevelopment that threatens existing neighborhoods #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589061740987580417
Excited to talk #publichistory & #activism w/ Nancy Berlage, Yolanda Chavez Leyva, @cathystanton, @DDMeringolo, & @DrDanKerr! #S27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Chelsea Denault (@Chelsea_Denault) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589061488981192704
@DDMeringolo "One big question: how did you decide where and how to put your experrtise to work?" #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589061236786081793
Ready to talk about historians and civic engagement and activism this morning for #s27 packed room! #ncph2015
— kristen baldwin deathridge (@k10death) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589060671272312832
@ddmeringolo: "This is not your grandfather's academic conference" #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DDMeringolo "not your grandfathers academic conference" love your enthusiasm and welcome! #ncph2015 #s27
— Rebecca Lawrence (@museumnotations) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589059902578020353
https://twitter.com/OliviaLane87/status/589059859775094784
"We're acknowledging that this work is a struggle … What we want to do is have ourselves put forward a different approach." #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
@DDMeringolo We all agree that it's hard work to define the edge between scholarship and politics– that there are tensions. #ncph2015 #s27
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589059626240499712
"Public history is by its very nature political" –@DDMeringolo #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
Institutional factors make us see activism as contrary to analysis #s27 #ncph2015
— Dr. Abigail R. Gautreau (@abbygateau) April 17, 2015
@DDMeringolo admits she's been "activ-ish" rather than an activist. Love the honesty this early in the morning. #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589058954539466752
#s27 #ncph2015 starting now. Hardball history!
— Adina Langer (@artiflection) April 17, 2015
https://twitter.com/amwhisnant/status/589058747949023232
https://twitter.com/lubar/status/589058349808951296
Day 2, here we go! First up, Hardball History with @DDMeringolo @cathystanton and @DrDanKerr #ncph2015 #s27
— Amelia T. Grabowski (@AmeliaTGrabow) April 17, 2015
Official note taker for #s27 Hardball History! #NCPH2015
— Courtney C. Hobson (@CuppaCourtney) April 17, 2015